What do I choose?!?

Almost every time I use Cyberduck these days, I’m confronted with this:

I consider this to be a horrible, horrible thing.

It asks me a “Yes” or “No” question, but only gives me the options of “Don’t Change” and “Change All.” Invariably, I always manage to select the wrong one, resetting all of my passwords and forcing me to reenter them countless times.

I understand this dialog box so little it hurts. I WANT Cyberduck to access the same keychain items as the previous version. I want to click “Yes,” but I can’t! Do I click “Don’t Change,” assuming that Cyberduck will then not change my passwords, retaining the old ones? Or do I click “Change All,” assuming Cyberduck will then change its keychain settings to access the old passwords? WHAT THE HELL DO I DO?